Valentina the Bear – $11,111Īs you might guess, Valentina was born on Valentine’s Day 1998. Whatever it is, it wasn’t lost on the buyer who placed the lone bid of $10,000. Instead, “Pinchers” supposedly features a different tag error that’s difficult to identify. The version with the “Punchers” tag is naturally highly coveted by collectors, but sadly, this is not one of them. Originally released as “Punchers” - perhaps in error - Pinchers is one of the original nine Beanie Babies. This one features an iridescent horn, a coarse yarn mane and - according to the seller - several tag errors. Mystic the Unicorn was born on May 21, 1994, with “magic in her blue eyes.” Still, he’s the third top-selling bear in all retired Beanie Babies on eBay, with one buyer considering Curly worth a cool $9,500.
He’s not a particularly uncommon bear - he’s known to have been given away at pro sporting events by the thousands in the late ’90s. Curly the Bear – $9,500Ĭurly is a brown bear with a dark red ribbon adorning his neck. In this article, we list the top 10 Beanie Babies that fetched the highest prices on eBay in 2021. Browse around online and you’ll likely notice that the most expensive Beanie Babies have a wide variety of prices, depending on where you look. Compiling a list like this can be a bit difficult because there’s no real consensus regarding the valuation of Beanie Babies.